A TSP loan doesn't create money. It converts invested shares into a fixed-rate receivable, and the real cost is the growth you give up plus the tax treatment of the interest.
Part 1 covered the basics.
Meet Sam: GS-09 (General Schedule grade 09) federal firefighter, age 28, $70,000 salary. TSP balance is $80,000, all traditional, allocated 60% C Fund (large U.S. stocks), 30% S Fund (small U.S. stocks), 10% I Fund (international stocks). He's contributing 5% to capture the full Federal Employees Retirement System (FERS) match. Sam has $10,000 in credit card debt at 22% annual percentage rate (APR) and takes a $10,000 general purpose TSP loan. The $50 fee comes out of the proceeds, so he nets $9,950. He pays that toward the card and covers the last $50 from his next paycheck.
Sam's shares get sold
The TSP doesn't lend Sam $10,000 from some cash pool. It sells $10,000 of his shares at the share price for the date the loan is posted. See 5 CFR 1655.9(a) and 5 CFR 1645.2. The rule says: "The amount borrowed will be removed from the participant's account when the loan is disbursed. Consequently, these funds will no longer generate earnings."
Sourcing is pro rata across every fund Sam holds. With his 60/30/10 allocation, the TSP sells:
- $6,000 of C Fund
- $3,000 of S Fund
- $1,000 of I Fund
Sam doesn't get to choose which fund the loan comes from. He can't say "sell from the I Fund only" or "preserve my C Fund." The pro-rata rule is automatic and non-discretionary.
What about Roth and traditional?
For Sam, this doesn't matter. He's traditional-only. But if he had a mixed balance, the sourcing would be pro rata across both traditional and Roth, also automatically. See 5 CFR 1655.9(c). The traditional/Roth split is locked in at disbursement and stays locked for the life of the loan. The fund mix is not locked. Repayments buy funds using Sam's current contribution allocation. See 5 CFR 1655.9(d). Part 3 walks through that asymmetry with Erin's mixed-balance example.
What about agency money?
Agency money is untouched. Per 5 CFR 1655.9(b), loans come only from your own contributions and the earnings attributable to those contributions. Sam's FERS 1% automatic and 4% matching dollars stay invested through the entire loan period. They keep earning whatever the market delivers.
What about share price timing?
Disbursement happens on a specific business day. The share price used is the price for the date the transaction is posted. 5 CFR 1645.2. If the C Fund closes at $90 a share on Sam's disbursement day, the TSP sells 66.667 shares to generate the $6,000. The $90 is a round number for this example; the actual price will differ. The fractional share precision is built into the system.
What Sam can't do: time the loan to disburse on a day with favorable share prices. The disbursement timing is driven by application processing, not market conditions.
Sam's principal becomes an IOU to himself
Once the shares are sold and Sam gets his $9,950, his account holds the remaining shares. The plan holds a $10,000 note receivable from Sam. The note is a plan asset, not part of Sam's account balance.
The FRTIB's audited financial statements confirm this directly. Outstanding TSP loans sit on the balance sheet as "Notes receivable from participants (loans)," measured at unpaid principal plus any accrued but unpaid interest. See the 2023 audited TSP financial statements. The note is an asset of the plan, just like the shares. It earns interest at the locked G Fund rate instead of generating equity market returns.
Sam's principal is not invested while it's outstanding. It is not in the C Fund, the S Fund, or cash. It is a receivable. The only return it generates is the interest Sam pays back through payroll deduction, which comes out of his after-tax wages.
While the loan is outstanding, you are paying yourself the G Fund rate on a balance that would otherwise be invested in whatever you'd chosen. Say you'd chosen the C Fund, which has averaged about 11.5% nominal since 1988, per the TSP rates of return. If the C Fund returns 10% during your loan window, you've converted $10,000 of C Fund exposure into a receivable earning the G Fund rate. You chose the timing, not the market.
The double taxation question
Sam's loan rate is the G Fund rate in effect when he requests the loan. The current rate is 4.875%, and I'm using it here. See the TSP Loans page. At 4.875%, the repayment schedule on a $10,000 loan over 60 months is $188.14 per month, $11,288.41 total. Of that, $10,000 is principal and $1,288.41 is interest.
The principal is not double-taxed. Walk through it: Sam earned wages, paid tax on them, and uses $10,000 of that after-tax money to repay the loan principal. Yes, that $10,000 sits in his traditional bucket and gets taxed again on withdrawal. But Sam got the original $10,000 of loan proceeds tax-free. That tax-free disbursement offsets the tax on his repayment dollars. Net effect on principal: zero extra tax versus just earning wages and not running them through a loan.
The interest is taxed twice in the cash-flow sense.
To pay $1,288.41 of interest from his paycheck, Sam needs about $1,652 in additional pre-tax wages (22% federal bracket, assuming he files single). The IRS takes $363. The $1,288 net goes into Sam's traditional TSP.
When Sam withdraws that $1,288 in retirement, it gets taxed again. At the same 22% rate, that's another $283.
Run the totals. Sam earned $1,652 of additional wages that became $1,288 of interest in his TSP. He paid:
- $363 in tax when he earned the wages
- $283 in tax when he withdraws the interest in retirement
- Total federal tax: $647 on $1,652 of additional wages
If Sam had simply earned that $1,652 and kept it in cash, he would have paid $363 in tax once. He'd have $1,288 to spend. The loan cycle added $283 in tax that wouldn't have existed in that comparison.
The interest is taxed twice in this comparison because there's no offsetting tax-free disbursement to balance it. The principal had that offset; the interest doesn't.
Harry Sit at The Finance Buff makes the counterpoint: the interest becomes pre-tax earnings in the plan. You would pay tax on any earnings when you withdraw them. The $283 is not an extra tax compared with other pre-tax investment earnings; it is the ordinary tax on a pre-tax account. The comparison above is a cash-flow comparison, not a total-wealth comparison. Both things are true. The interest is paid with after-tax dollars and taxed again at withdrawal. That is also how any pre-tax earnings in the plan are treated.
Christine Benz and Michael Kitces at Morningstar discuss the same trade-off and put the bigger cost on the foregone growth, not the interest tax.
This applies to all traditional 401(k)-style plan loans, not just TSP. For qualified Roth distributions, the interest isn't double-taxed: both sides of the cycle are post-tax and the withdrawal is tax-free. Nonqualified Roth distributions can still tax earnings.
The share price you "sold at" doesn't really matter
TSP fund share prices are arbitrary accounting units. Every TSP fund started at $10 when the TSP moved to daily share accounting in 2003. The L 2075 Fund launched at $10 in June 2025. The TSP could redenominate every share tomorrow, giving you twice as many shares at half the price. The dollar value of your account would not change by one cent. Chris Barfield has the cleanest explanation.
What matters for Sam's loan is whether the underlying indexes move up or down between when he sold and when his repayments buy back in.
Bull market scenario
Sam takes the loan today. Over the next 5 years, the C Fund returns an average of 8% annually. His repayments of $188.14 per month buy back C Fund shares at progressively higher prices. By the end of year 5, the C Fund equivalent he's rebuilt through repayments is worth about $13,700. Left alone, the original $10,000 would have grown to about $14,700. The gap at the end of year 5: roughly $970. That's the opportunity cost during the loan window itself.
Bear market scenario
Same loan, different market. Over the next 5 years, the C Fund declines an average of 3% annually. Sam's repayments buy back C Fund shares at progressively lower prices. He may end up with more C Fund shares than he started with. Their dollar value at the end of year 5 is about $10,500. If he had held the original $10,000, it would be worth about $8,600. The loan comes out about $1,900 ahead in this scenario.
This isn't an argument for taking TSP loans during downturns. The bear scenario advantage is real, but the market path is unpredictable, and the same loan can cost you in a rising market.
The real cost over 30 years
Sam is 28. The opportunity cost during the 5-year loan window is one thing. The long-horizon cost is something else.
At 7% real (inflation-adjusted) returns, $10,000 left invested in the C Fund for 30 years grows to about $76,000 in today's dollars. By the time Sam is in his late 50s and approaching retirement, that single $10,000 contribution would have become a substantial chunk of his TSP balance.
When Sam takes the loan, he interrupts that compounding. During the 5-year repayment window, his repayments rebuild the position but at progressively higher share prices in a typical rising market. Even crediting the interest he pays himself back into the account, the long-run trajectory is lower than if he'd never borrowed.
Sam's $10,000 in the C Fund grows for an average of 27.5 years, not the full 30. The loan suspends about 2.5 years of compounding on the principal. The interest he pays himself ($1,288 over 5 years) grows for about 25 to 27 years on average.
Running this at 7% real:
- Path A (no loan): $10,000 × (1.07^30) = $76,123 in year 30
- Path B (loan): roughly $72,700 in year 30, after accounting for the interrupted compounding on principal and the additional interest contributions
The net cost over 30 years: about $3,400 of foregone retirement balance. The number varies with assumptions about when the interest is paid and the return used.
The $50 fee is the visible cost. The $1,288 of interest is money you pay back into your own account. It is not a fee, but it creates the tax question above. The opportunity cost is the bigger hit, and nobody hands Sam an invoice for it.
This number gets bigger the younger you are and the larger the loan is. A 28-year-old taking a $10,000 loan loses more in retirement dollars than a 52-year-old taking the same loan. The younger borrower has more years of compounding to lose.
What's next
Part 3 introduces Erin and walks through how repayment works. It covers the rule that locks her traditional/Roth split at the disbursement proportions while her fund allocation follows her current contribution election.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice, investment advice, tax advice, or legal advice. The information is based on current regulations and best practices as of the publication date. Your individual financial situation is unique, and you should consult with a qualified financial advisor, tax professional, or legal counsel before making any financial decisions. Matthew Stelmaszek, EA, ChFC®, MQFP®, and Stellar Wealth Management do not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of any information presented. They are not responsible for any errors or omissions, or for results obtained from the use of this information.
